Understanding The "POWER SCALE" | One Piece Discussion

コメント数

  1. Hōrnetto

    Hōrnetto19 時間 前

    Posting this comment only halfway through the video but i agree with alot of your points. a lot of powerscalers take alot of things as absolute fact even when all the details havent been given. Take Kaido for instance. The Manga and anime only states that he hasnt been able to be KILLED no matter how many people try, not that he cant be beaten (obviously he can if he was captured but so many times)

  2. Ykc 4

    Ykc 43 日 前

    To me it seems that while navy sends out admirals , the reason they do is because the ones who need to be brought “Justice” are not admiral level but no one below a admiral can do anything to them it’s more like a post gap in the marines. You can’t send a crew of smoker to kill a luffy you need a admiral doesn’t exactly mean luffy will beat a admiral with a crew any day .

  3. Az

    Az9 日 前

    Your power scaling is wrong

  4. Az

    Az9 日 前

    There is a set formular

  5. East Blue

    East Blue17 日 前

    Another one, In One PIece, when a character is a leader, and his/her commanders are so OP, it means their leader or captain is even more OP than them. Because power is respected in One Piece.

  6. East Blue

    East Blue17 日 前

    In One Piece, when a character is stated to be "The Greatest", or "the Strongest" or "The whatever-est" is, it means they are what they are.

  7. z Romanz

    z Romanz24 日 前

    i think garp is a monster thats why sengoku rush to stop him. and the navy said he is the "best guardian we have" and whitebeard say his name

  8. Terrell Craig

    Terrell Craig25 日 前

    Bro I didn’t know you was black 🤣😂

  9. god pig

    god pig26 日 前

    Kaido is the strongest, but prime white beard still weaker than akainu, big mom and kizaru though. Shanks and Blackbeard are weaker than akoji. Shanks literally has no feats while his only feat is blocking heavily injured akainu's normal punch with his blade. Mean while, Oda stated kaido is the strongest many times.prime Shanks who has two hands is still weaker than mihawk, and now the gap is only greater. Blackbeard gets wrecked by luffy's second gear punch. Jack get beat up by cats and dogs haki blade and sustain no damage. Kaido >akainu=big mom>kizaru>mihawk>akoji>shanks=Blackbeard>fujitora

  10. god pig

    god pig26 日 前

    garp and sengouku should be weaker than fujitora. Prime garp only slightly weaker than akoji. Prime z equal to fujitora. Prime roger equal to mihawk. Ben Beckman weaker than king. Ace weaker than snacker and post time skip zoro and smoker

  11. Johan Nyamsy

    Johan Nyamsy26 日 前

    Who's stronger: Magellan VS Kuma?

  12. Josiah Baumgartner

    Josiah Baumgartnerヶ月 前

    You made some seriously garbage points but that's okay. Still liked the video

  13. Edward Newgate

    Edward Newgateヶ月 前

    Power scaling is fun but the point is not that power scaling is toxic, it is that some people are pushing their own head canon that is toxic. An example is with Shanks, I always found it dumb that there are people always saying that he is the strongest Yonko even when there is no proof whatsoever or that he is a Yonko with only one ship, like come on, he must have a fleet of ally ships as well as we have seen, you only really become a Yonko when you have power, fleets and feats. My only real advice is that people need to stop using head canon.

  14. Roderick Cheathum

    Roderick Cheathumヶ月 前

    Luffy and Kidd vs Kaido final battle am I the only one who thinks this make a video please lol we know Kidd ain’t letting his treatment go 😂

  15. Couch Commando

    Couch Commandoヶ月 前

    I would do a Tier List instead of numbered. Because it is as unclear as it is to give a character a definitive number, I think we can all agree a little better who is tiered where. It does require figuring the top X characters so you are not having to figure out what Tier Nami is in, and you have a decent size pool of characters to work with.

  16. Rey Montalvo

    Rey Montalvoヶ月 前

    LoL Dragon looks like he bout to say to Akainu u messed with wrong Ssj 😂

  17. pigtailed pete the pancake penetrator

    pigtailed pete the pancake penetratorヶ月 前

    Raditz looks cool in the thumbnail

  18. Goondof

    Goondofヶ月 前

    I feel like dragons df is logia of wind and he can basically disappear because his logia is wind and he already has his awakening which would be like able to create storms or something.

  19. Chaz Young

    Chaz Youngヶ月 前

    And I love the Videos

  20. Chaz Young

    Chaz Youngヶ月 前

    I think only white beard and Roger was actually fighting in my interpretation it was stated that this flashback is basically a journal that Oden was writing in and it says that they were fighting And in the panels only Roger and white beard clash if I’m not mistaken

  21. Kiryoku Gaming

    Kiryoku Gamingヶ月 前

    I gotta say, I love your commentary. Your logic, knowledge, and your voice. Top tier

  22. WaterparkRanger

    WaterparkRangerヶ月 前

    For One Piece and other series I see the gaps of strength between characters measured by the feats either depicted or strongly suggested. If I made a top 30 list for One Piece I think I would have to leave off Dragon for now, I can only make assumptions about where he falls. Although he's the leader of his own team, the leader is not always the strongest one. I think there is a high chance Dragon is the strongest of the revolutionaries but I would keep him off any top list until there is more evidence. He's just an example. And I agree that it's a dumb thing to be mad about, but this what nerds do. Most of them are just memeing anyway.

  23. Tekka579

    Tekka579ヶ月 前

    Shanks didn't do anything, did we not see him shut down the war? Did we not see Alkinus face when he stopped him from killing Kolby? Baffled

  24. 12shzarmai 55

    12shzarmai 55ヶ月 前

    I totally agree with you BDA

  25. Dawayne Brown

    Dawayne Brownヶ月 前

    Personal opinion clouds the whole scaling situation, for example , the fans say Whitebeard may have been stronger than Rodger because he was his rival despite having a "WEAKER" crew. However the manga portrays the two crews to be equal in terms of strength. Also it took the combination of whitebeards df and haki to cancel out Rodgers haki alone.

  26. Freeza Senpai

    Freeza Senpaiヶ月 前

    Did corcus say roger was able to fight at full strength

  27. kion127

    kion127ヶ月 前

    The thing with Rayleigh wanting to save the Straw Hats is that he wouldn't need to defeat Kizaru, all he'd need to do is delay the pacifista and Sentimaru long enough for the Straw Hats an opening to get away. But since he's not in his prime he couldn't create an opening that would give him enough time to stop fighting Kizaru for a few moments to intervene with the other enemies. The Pacifista and Sentomaru were on Luffy and company non stop, but if he could get them off the straw hats for a few moments then they'd have a better chance of escape.

  28. Kyle Jones

    Kyle Jonesヶ月 前

    This is silly. Clearly buggy is the strongest character.

  29. Sean Omari

    Sean Omariヶ月 前

    With the fate of the universe on the line The old dogs are still strong as ever. Shanks might be the only one everyone have to be wary of as well as Dragon.

  30. Mickey Swish

    Mickey Swishヶ月 前

    Yeahhhh boi, I feel you. No one will ever have the same mindset when it comes to anything. You acknowledging the fact and giving reason, won you my subscription! I personally don’t like using the term “admiral level” or “commander level” for the fact of Jesus Burges does not compare to Katakuri in my mind. But are both “commander level”. Great video

  31. Zachary Smith

    Zachary Smithヶ月 前

    Bro. Good video. I am up to date AF. But watching luffy climb the mountain for chopper will never get old. The new world (,doflamingo included) has never pushed Luffy. Luffy died like 3 times in alabasta. He only won , because his will and emotions were present in his final attack (pushes through sabre)

  32. PolyColdfFuseVideo

    PolyColdfFuseVideoヶ月 前

    Bro where do you buy your anime merch bruh I need that cap and them sweaters. If you can get an affiliate links too that would be cool. Want to support you. 😎 Also this is a great partner video to King of Lighting's How To Power Scale A Character.jpreporter.net/v/%E3%83%93%E3%83%87%E3%82%AA-_d32vUSYdF4.html I watch it because I power scale my characters in some what Oda way with an avatar the last airbender feel.

  33. Undo Wednesday

    Undo Wednesdayヶ月 前

    Power scaling doesn't exist because of plot. Plot > Scaling

  34. Bobby Wayne

    Bobby Wayneヶ月 前

    Why wasnt Sengoku on the list ?

  35. Vivek Chhetry

    Vivek Chhetryヶ月 前

    I understand one piece way better because of him♥️♥️♥️

  36. Bobby Wayne

    Bobby Wayneヶ月 前

    Tier lists are maybe a better fit for the one piece universe

  37. Dylan Adalian

    Dylan Adalianヶ月 前

    Where can i get a hat like that?

  38. Brock Baker

    Brock Bakerヶ月 前

    That hoodie was the best part of this video great video but that hoodie tho

  39. As'ad Muhammad

    As'ad Muhammadヶ月 前

    At last there is someone who has a same opinion on power scaling in one piece. I agree. Totally agree with you.

  40. Son Of Shanks

    Son Of Shanksヶ月 前

    prime garp looks like Gear 4th

  41. Do Thang Bui

    Do Thang Buiヶ月 前

    moshpit of opinions hahaha nice one

  42. paperclipp

    paperclippヶ月 前

    What up man. We also don’t tealy know what the title “the dark king” means. What if we find out it’s some fucked up shit. Something power wise.

  43. greycane

    greycaneヶ月 前

    Do you think that Oda has list of the strongest and where he would rank them. Obviously it would shift as Luffy and co. get stronger.

  44. Monkey D. Luffy

    Monkey D. Luffyヶ月 前

    Watch LUFFY LATEST G4 Form!wow jpreporter.net/v/%E3%83%93%E3%83%87%E3%82%AA-w6Z_wUgsB5M.html

  45. jinky maambong

    jinky maambongヶ月 前

    u luk lyk lbj

  46. Moses Kuku

    Moses Kukuヶ月 前

    Luffy won cause his conquers was better than KAT? Will power over awakening and raw strength

  47. Anime Movies Music & Others

    Anime Movies Music & Othersヶ月 前

    1. Shanks 2. Dragon 3. Kaido 4. BM 5. Akainu 6. BB 7.Aokiji / Kizaru 8. Mihawk

  48. Derek Whitfield

    Derek Whitfieldヶ月 前

    Do you expect fan mail.?

  49. Benjoe Cua

    Benjoe Cuaヶ月 前

    Just a theory what if aokiji shows up in wano and help luffy?

  50. Mahadi Alam

    Mahadi Alamヶ月 前

    Top 1 is the worlds greatest loser respect the title

  51. Inari

    Inariヶ月 前

    Well goddamn you cute asf.

  52. Lyricist Productions

    Lyricist Productionsヶ月 前

    I think it’s toxic you mentioned shanks feats without talking about him stopping Kaido and the marine ford war . Without a scratch.😂

  53. buuri winsto

    buuri winstoヶ月 前

    Lyricist Productions still greater than any of the current yonkou feats lol. Unless you think Kaidou getting whooped by Oden & Big mom getting knocked out and losing memory by a commander are great feats of course Dont forget the only reason whitebeard was Yonkou Level was because he was old and dying. If he was young and healthy he would wipe his ass with the current yonkou ;)

  54. Lyricist Productions

    Lyricist Productionsヶ月 前

    buuri winsto I think the problem about akainu was his greatest feat was killing a dying sick and jumped old white beard 😂

  55. buuri winsto

    buuri winstoヶ月 前

    Lyricist Productions Punking blackbeard crew vs crew was indeed a feat. Now punking blackbeard & his crew SOLO after just fighting in a huge war is a much bigger feat (Sakazuki) Not comparing Akainu with Shanks or vice versa, Imo they're both Top tier monsters. Just saying people always give yonkou credit where they wont give it to an admiral. I cant even imagine the wank an emperor wouldve gotten if he did that to The blackbeard pirates on his own.

  56. Lyricist Productions

    Lyricist Productionsヶ月 前

    @buuri winsto stopping a war and punking blackbeard was a strength feat 🤦🏾‍♂️

  57. Lyricist Productions

    Lyricist Productionsヶ月 前

    @buuri winsto what could he have offered for him to waste a trip that far? To get someone he really wanted to get ? 🤔.

  58. jay free

    jay freeヶ月 前

    LMAO you're not doing yourself any good

  59. OGdyspo 42

    OGdyspo 42ヶ月 前

    Pretty sure that Naruto is the strongest in One Piece aye.

  60. Roberto Torruella

    Roberto Torruellaヶ月 前

    I heard that Gol D. Roger and Garp teamed up to take down Rocks D. Xebecs but Roger was whitebeard rival according to one piece

  61. Roberto Torruella

    Roberto Torruellaヶ月 前

    Dragon could be a former admiral or trained by garp before seeing how garp made luffy into a hardheaded grandson he wanted

  62. Ichimakiluf The One & Only

    Ichimakiluf The One & Onlyヶ月 前

    Hey bra I really like all ur VIDEOS. U keep me updated on everything. Keep doing wat ur doing my brotha.

  63. Superfrankytien

    Superfrankytienヶ月 前

    I agree that you should just ignore the toxicity because its not worth your time. Even though everyone has their own ideas/opinions its best to be respectful of other views, even if they are 100% counter to yours. Example: Someone tells me Franky is the weakest Strawhat. My response won't be to insult you, only that I personally disagree. And thats where, as a community, we can have interesting and positive discussions.

  64. Ahl Andrie

    Ahl Andrieヶ月 前

    I dont have time for 16 mins video but if he didnt say Buggy is top1 this whole thing bullshit

  65. Chev555

    Chev555ヶ月 前

    i don't think u can actually rank some characters above others, a lot of them to me are about the same level of power. My top ten: 1. Xebec 2. Whitebeard/roger/Garp 3. Dragon 4. Sengoku/Kong/Shiki 5. Shanks 6. Kaido 7. Oden/Mihawk/Ryuma/Rayleigh (all could win/lose to each other) 8. Big Mom 9. Blackbeard 10. Aokiji/Akainu (honestly for me they are the same because it seems like the fight could have gone either way)

  66. chris anderson

    chris andersonヶ月 前

    Love this damn video, great discussion,and you definitely altered my view on power scaling id definitely say now top 3 so far are Rocks (1) Roger (2) then Garp(3) just for the fact that the entire time we thought rogers era was the apex he was the most powerful just for GARP TO BE LIKE, yea son me the top strongest marine and the would be pirate king had to TEAM up to deal with him in his crew, the WG was shook when Shanks and Whitebeard were just “Meeting” and Rocks was so threatening to the workd that he forced the TOP marine and Gol D Roger just to take him down.

  67. PheonixOrchid

    PheonixOrchidヶ月 前

    i understand your argument and i disagree with a lot

  68. Temujin18S

    Temujin18Sヶ月 前

    @PheonixOrchid That's not enough though there's no concrete proof plus full context to certain battles. Especially when deciding whose superior to who. Brago argument is not something you contest against. Your point about Luffy's mastery just proofs he's point.

  69. PheonixOrchid

    PheonixOrchidヶ月 前

    i power scale basically solely through portrayal. who stopped how, the implied or shown how, haki, df use and mastery.. (can we talk about how it seems Luffy has mastery over his fruit but as far as paramecia are concerned hasnt been portrayed to have full mastery)

  70. iman tajer

    iman tajerヶ月 前

    When one piece ends we can power scale all we want CORRECTLY Bda law expect from where you placed mihawk your list is pretty good

  71. Rafael De Jesus Diaz

    Rafael De Jesus Diazヶ月 前

    I carry the simple thought that Yonko's are top tier. 1 Admiral gets slapped by a Yonko. 2 can contest and likely beat said Yonko in a mixed high to extreme difficulty fight (I don't believe that any of the Yonko, with the exception of Blackbeard, wouldn't be able to fight these odds). 3 can absolutely beat said Yonko in a mid-dif fight.

  72. Luis Meraz

    Luis Merazヶ月 前

    Lol the edit. Looks like you are glitching lol

  73. Duke Savage

    Duke Savageヶ月 前

    Portrayal/the role the characters will play in the story is the most important to consider imo. Crocodile clashed "evenly" with Mihawk, so did Vista, but no one, on their right minds, thinks those two are remotely close to him, but why? Because Mihawk's portrayal/role in the story, he's the World Strongest Swordsman and Zoro's end goal to achieve his dream, Mihawk HAS to be that much stronger than Crocodile and Vista, because it's what the story needs from him, it's not a few casual clashes that will change that. The Yonkou, aside from BB, are stepping stones for Luffy, simple as that. Doesn't matter how much it's fanboys try to deny, BM and Kaidou are just (big) stepping stones in Luffy's way and Shanks is his inspiration, they can't be the current strongest of the world, because that's not what the story wants from them. Akainu and BB were explicitly highlighted by Oda after time skip with Jinbe; "there are two things you must know, Akainu became Fleet Admiral and the Navy is stronger than ever under him and BB made his move to become a Yonkou", those are the two enemies that Oda is building for Luffy, there's no way they are (or will be in BB's case) weaker than past oponents Luffy had, whose only role in the story was to build up Luffy to fight these two.

  74. Vader

    Vaderヶ月 前

    Brago you should do a top 5 skipped fights video.

  75. zoro erikson

    zoro eriksonヶ月 前

    brago you went from saying “we need more context” to talking about the scar on shanks. we don’t know the context of that fight. please educate me on how you cherry pick your arguments?

  76. Brago D. Ace

    Brago D. Aceヶ月 前

    This is a dumb take. You literally cherry picked this... ridiculous

  77. Grizzly Magnum

    Grizzly Magnumヶ月 前

    Lore/theories/explanations are way better then power scaling in my opinion. I get more excited/I’m more interested

  78. Imran Zakir

    Imran Zakirヶ月 前

    i have been saying this whole time that you cannot compare the feats of Whitebeard with the current yonko and downplay admirals on the basis of that....Whitebeard was old but still the strongest in fact many characters including doflamingo said WB was holding the reins until he died i am sure other yonko's are nasty and if they thought WB was weak they won't let go of such opportunity ....Akainu is treated like a scrub because he lost to WB and i know it's bs because WB was a powerhouse and no yonko was close in power with him.i put Akainu in the same level as current yonko just on the basis of how he was holding up against WB.People also shit on Big mom when Kaido got his introduction overhyping him and underestimating Big mom.I will say in clear words Kaido and Shanks are hyped way too much and their fans are most toxic.

  79. Brandon Lambert

    Brandon Lambertヶ月 前

    Going off BDA Law talking about Conqueror's Haki, I think it plays a big part because the way I view it is as a power boost to the other Haki. So if your Conqueror's Haki is higher than your opponent then the rest follow and you should be able to overpower the enemy

  80. DjDedan

    DjDedanヶ月 前

    In my top 30 Garth is Numero Zero!

  81. Brandon Lambert

    Brandon Lambertヶ月 前

    Let's just all agree the power scaling in One Piece was great and has slowly turned to garbage kinda like the woman character designs (used to be all over the place with looks now everyone has the same ridiculous curves) Also the largest problem is we have no history about 1v1 battles or past storylines between these other characters because Oda is focusing solely on the StarwHat's journey. This is why we need spin off manga to see Garp/Roger, WB/Roger, Xebec/Garp/Roger, Aokiji/Akainu, Kidd/Apoo/Urogue/Hawkins/Bege, Kaido/Big Mom, Mihawk/Shanks, Kuma/Marines, etc... doing full out battles and 1v1's in order to be able to scale a winner even though it is very close

  82. king zaxa

    king zaxaヶ月 前

    The power scale in one piece is bull. When you have a guy who has only been a pirate for 2 years beating dudes who are way more experienced than him with power ups and friendship boost yk u have a problem

  83. Jay Swish16

    Jay Swish16ヶ月 前

    king zaxa Luffy has never had a friendship boost this ain't Fairy tail 😂

  84. Erik Burgos

    Erik Burgosヶ月 前

    Power scaling wont matter after law dies and chopper gets the ope ope no mi

  85. Mr. Read

    Mr. Readヶ月 前

    Plot twist: Buggy is the top character...

  86. Outsider 001

    Outsider 001ヶ月 前

    He looks a little like gajeel in the thumbnail

  87. AT TV

    AT TVヶ月 前

    The problem is you're ignoring Whitebeards health at marineford, whereas Rayleigh though old appears to be relatively healthy.

  88. firefisttre

    firefisttreヶ月 前

    I personally find your power scaling vids entertaining and I find that your points make sense. I just think people need to just have open discussions and stop taking it way too seriously

  89. diumer777

    diumer777ヶ月 前

    Ik my comment may be 1 out of zillion, but one piece from my pvo just make characters as strong as they need to be at sertain arks, this may look like an odvious answer, but if you were a bleach fan ud know how boring ichigo was at moments when it was implied that he was already strong he just did not know it, back to one piece oda makes it thrill when you see a new guy cuz they looks invincible. Just hope they dont run out of plot armor and bring the 7 dragonballs bandage.

  90. Henry Walker

    Henry Walkerヶ月 前

    How does shiryu make the list and Magellan doesn't when shiryu based on feats and hype he is clearly below Magellan